You’re halfway through your custard when your cute dog gives you the puppy eye treatment and begs for some.
You’re aware that there are some human foods she shouldn’t eat, but you’re not sure if custard falls into that category.
Should you let your dog lick your bowl or give her her own small bowl of custard?
Can Dogs Eat Custard?
Custard is safe for dogs to eat, but only in very small amounts and without additives like vanilla or chocolate.
The ingredients in Custards aren’t necessarily toxic, but they aren’t good for your dog’s health either. Overfeeding your dog Custards may lead to obesity, stomach upset, and even tooth decay.
What is Custard?
Custard is a delicious dessert or snack that tastes a lot like Fortune cookies. Texture and taste can be quite different. Depending on the recipe, custard can take the form of either a thick pastry cream or a thin sauce. Vanilla is the predominant flavor in custards.
Custard comes in many forms, such as:
- Custard that has been baked.
- Custard in the form of pastry cream.
- Custard in powder form.
- Frozen Custard.
- Stirred Custard.
- Ultra-high temperature (UHT) Custard.
- Custard made with eggs.
What is in Custard?

Custard can be made in a variety of ways, but the following are standard components:
- Flavored milk, cream, or both.
- Cheese.
- Yolks and eggs, obviously.
- Sugar.
- Extracts and essences, such as vanilla.
Starches that are used to thicken a dish are sometimes added, and these can range from flour and arrowroot to corn and potato starches and even gelatin. Custard is thickened primarily by egg yolks and sometimes by whole eggs, so this step is optional.
What follows is a breakdown of the constituent parts:
Caster sugar (Not recommended for dogs)
Dogs can safely consume fruit sugars, but caster sugar should be avoided. A high-sugar diet can lead to tooth decay, insulin resistance, and weight gain in canines.
Sweets and candies that are extremely high in sugar or artificial sweeteners, like caster sugar, should be avoided. The same is true for dogs; they are poisonous to them.
Risks of caster sugar:
- Issues with one’s teeth or gums.
- Diabetes
- Gaining Weight
- Depression
Double cream (Not recommended for dogs)
Lactose intolerance makes dairy products difficult to digest for some dogs. Additionally, dogs shouldn’t consume cream because of the milk that’s already in it.
Risks of cream:
- GI distress
Whole milk (Not recommended for dogs)
The following symptoms may occur in dogs after they consume dairy products:
Risks of whole milk:
- Vomiting
- Diarrhea
- Irritated stomach
Egg yolks (Safe for dogs)
Eggs, which are rich in protein, nutrients, and amino acids, can be fed to dogs without risk. Eggs are fine, but remember that dogs should only have a few.
Benefits of egg yolks:
- Gives dogs the nutrients they need, including protein, fatty acids, and amino acids
- To ease stomach distress
- Calcium-rich food
Risks of eggs:
- Excessive consumption can lead to weight gain and high cholesterol in canines.
- Salmonella poisoning from feeding raw eggs to canines.
Corn flour (Safe for dogs)
Dogs can eat corn flour without worry. It’s possible that your dog’s food contains corn flour and you don’t even know it. Its primary application is in the baking industry, where it serves as a thickener. Dogs do not benefit nutritionally from eating corn flour.
Vanilla Extract (Not recommended for dogs)

Alcohol is found in high concentrations in vanilla extract. There’s a chance that alcohol won’t be metabolized properly by your dog’s digestive system.
Vanilla extract can cause alcohol poisoning in dogs if they eat too much of it. To be on the safe side with your dog, try to find vanilla extract that does not contain alcohol.
Risks of vanilla extract:
- Feeling sick to one’s stomach
- Lack of air to breathe
Butter (Not recommended for dogs)
Butter is safe for dogs to consume, but it offers no nutritional value and is high in fat with no positive effects on the dog’s health. Because butter is made from milk, it could be problematic for your dog’s digestion if it is lactose intolerant.
Risks of butter:
- Obesity
- A stomachache
Is Custard bad for dogs?
Too much custard can be harmful to your dog. Generally speaking, the more delicious the Custard, the more risky it is for your dog.
For instance, many people would prefer a high-fat Custard to a low-fat one due to the former’s creamier texture and more robust flavor. However, did you know that it accounts for only 6%
Dairy products like milk and cream are not good for dogs, and so is custard.
There are a few things to keep in mind before feeding your pets Custard:
Most dogs are lactose intolerant
Most dogs are lactose intolerant because they lack an adequate amount of lactase, an enzyme necessary for digesting the lactose found in dairy products like milk and cream. Consequently, they have an impaired ability to metabolize dairy products such as milk and cream.
Don’t worry too much if your dog ate a tiny bit of Custard by accident. But make sure your dog can’t get to the Custard.
If your dog ate a lot of Custard by mistake, you should take him to the vet immediately. If your furry friend consumes a lot of Custard, they have likely consumed too much milk, which can cause the following symptoms:
- Bloating.
- Constant belching.
- Diarrhea.
- Having loose stools.
- Vomiting.
- Torment in the gut.
Danger of Sugar
Sugar gives custard its pleasant flavor. However, excess sugar can be harmful to your dog’s health, leading to issues like obesity, tooth decay, and even diabetes.
Dogs frequently suffer from periodontal disease. In fact, by the time they’re 3 years old, 80% of dogs already have some sort of dental problem.
Thus, let’s take care that Custard doesn’t exacerbate a problem that is already quite widespread and potentially fatal in canines.
Dogs should be fine if you only give them a tiny bit of Custard, as the small amount of sugar in it won’t hurt them. Custard can be given to your furry friends once every few months as a special treat.
Danger of Flavoring

Do not feed your dog any Custard that has been flavored with chocolate. Because it contains both theobromine and caffeine, chocolate is extremely toxic to dogs. Ingesting either of these substances could be fatal for a dog. The higher the percentage of cocoa solids in chocolate, the more toxic it is to your dog.
How do I make Custard for my dog at home?
Worry not if your dog is sniffing at your Custard and you don’t want to share. The Custard is easy enough to make on your own. In any case, here are some potential solutions.
Make a Custard for your dog with these dog-friendly ingredients:
- Use half a teaspoon of salt.
- Add 3 tbsp of cornstarch.
- Two egg yolks.
- Half a liter of water equals half a can of evaporated milk.
- Vanilla extract, one teaspoon’s worth.
Canine-friendly alternatives to Custard
You shouldn’t feed your dog Custard if you aren’t familiar with all of the ingredients. Instead, consider these treats that are perfectly fine for your four-legged friends:
Popsicles made from fresh fruit, made at home
Make your own frozen fruit popsicles instead of buying Custard. So now you know exactly what goes into these delicious snacks.
The combination of pumpkin, xylitol-free peanut butter, and mashed bananas with low-fat plain yogurt or low-sodium chicken broth is delicious.
Put them in the freezer for about two to three hours, and your dog will have a tasty and nutritious treat.
In the summer, we love to give our dogs these icy treats:
What if my dog accidentally ate a lot of Custard?
Don’t freak out if your dog suddenly consumed a large amount of Custard. In the next few hours, you should keep a close eye on him. Find out what went into the Custard he ate. Assuming your pet is not lactose intolerant and the Custard doesn’t contain any poisonous ingredients, he should be fine after eating it.
If he has an allergy to lactose and the Custard also contains chocolate or xylitol, you should take him to the vet immediately. If your dog is visibly trembling and his temperature is rising, you should take him to the vet immediately. It’s even possible that some canines will throw up or experience diarrhea.
What can I do if my dog consumes large amounts of custard without my consent?
Don’t panic, but keep a close eye on your dog for the next few hours if she eats a lot of custard by accident.
Find out what went into the custard she ate in the meantime.
It’s safe to assume she won’t have any adverse reactions if the product doesn’t contain any harmful ingredients and she doesn’t have a lactose intolerance.
But if she has a dairy allergy, or if the custard she ate contained chocolate, you should take her to the vet right away, especially if your puppy exhibits any of the signs we’ve listed above (diarrhea, vomiting, muscle tremors, elevated body temperature, etc.).
Related Questions:
Can dogs eat frozen Custard?
The answer is no, frozen Custard is not safe for canines. Custard is extremely toxic to dogs because it contains sugar, flavorings, and milk, regardless of whether it has been frozen or not.
Can dogs eat Custard ice cream?
Custard ice cream is not safe for dogs to eat because it contains sugar, milk, and artificial flavors that can be harmful to them. You shouldn’t feed your dog ice cream, especially custard ice cream, because it’s loaded with sugar.
Also, your dog probably won’t be able to handle the dairy in it. An upset stomach, diarrhea, and possibly vomiting are all possible side effects for your dog.
Can dogs eat Custard creams?
Custard creams are not safe for dogs to eat. The high sugar content, like that of Custard ice cream, has been linked to a variety of behavioral changes in dogs, including irritability, hyperactivity, and depression. There are a number of long-term health issues that could affect your dog, including dental disease, diabetes, and obesity.
Can dogs eat Custard tarts?
Canines should not consume Custard Tarts, unfortunately. You shouldn’t give them to your dog because of how high in sugar they are. Indeed, Custard tarts may cause stomach distress in your dog.
Can dogs eat Custard pie?
If a Custard pie has milk, sugar, or flavoring, it is not safe for a dog to eat it.
Can dogs eat Custard apples?
Custard apples are not safe for canine consumption. Some seeds can be harmful if your furry friend ingests them by accident. Keep an eye out for him. Get in touch with your veterinarian right away if you notice any symptoms. If your dog has eaten a Custard apple by mistake, it is important to give him plenty of water.
Can dogs eat Rita’s Custard?
No, Rita’s Custard is not safe for canine consumption. It’s no secret that Rita’s Custard is a popular chain of eateries and a delicious dessert. Rita’s Custard might give your dog a pup cup if you bring it in with you.
Can dogs eat Culver’s Custard?
No, Culver’s Custard is not safe for canine consumption. There are dog biscuits and dog-friendly ice cream served with a milk bone, but no Culver’s Custard. Replace the Custard with these.
Can dogs eat vanilla Custard?
Although dogs shouldn’t be fed vanilla custard, a small amount given on occasion is fine.
Parting Thoughts
While custard has many health benefits, it should never be fed to a dog.
Give your dog some healthy options like frozen pumpkin, mashed banana, or peanut butter the next time it begs.